Custom Orthotics vs Insoles - Which is Right for You? (2024)

Foot pain is quite common. When a person experiences foot-related issues, there are products that can help. An individual can choose between custom orthotics and insoles. It is important to understand the differences so that a person can select the most effective item for relief.

What are Insoles?

Insoles, also called inserts, are commonly found on store shelves. Usually, they are crafted from a soft material that cradles the foot. Foam, plastic, and gel are most commonly used. Many times, a person chooses insoles to solve problems like fallen arches. The main focus is to provide cushioning and shock absorption.

Insoles provide a cushion to the foot and added support. This helps decrease pain into the short-term. In this manner, insoles are better for individuals who do not suffer with constant foot discomfort. They are effective to use as preventative care on feet, especially when a person is participating in activities that require standing for long periods of time. Unfortunately, these products are not made to address underlying problems. This means that pain and other symptoms will continue and may become worse. It is important to have problems diagnosed by a medical professional.

Different Kinds of Insoles

There are three varieties of insoles.

  • Foam. Generally, foam inserts offer a low level of comfort to feet. However, they only deliver minimal support to arches. Foam tends to degrade fast as well. Many times, a person will only be able to use them for a few weeks before another pair is needed.
  • Gel. Gel insoles offer more support than foam counterparts. However, they are still not firm enough to help with long-term problems.
  • Rigid Inserts. Rigid insoles are commonly crafted from molded plastic. They offer support to a foot’s heel or arch, but they can get uncomfortable.

What are Orthotics?

Orthotics are in the same category as inserts. However, they are custom fit. Insoles are manufactured to help the masses, but orthotics are specially crafted for one person’s feet. Since they fit perfectly, effectiveness is increased. They raise the likelihood of lowering pain and successfully correcting foot issues.

Even though both insoles and custom orthotics cushion feet, orthotics can correct the way that a person stands and walks. When a person’s feet are even slightly misaligned or are having issues, it has a negative impact on his or her entire body. For instance, a person’s knees, shins, and back are all linked to his or her feet. Orthotics can correct problems by evenly spreading pressure around the feet. Also, they help to ensure that feet hit the ground properly with every step.

If an individual has been having pain for a regular period of time, orthotics are the best option for relief. They bring results that are quick and noticeable. Custom orthotics eliminate pain by supporting and realigning bones and ligaments in feet.

Different Types of Custom Orthotics

In certain places, kiosks are available to take scans of people’s feet. Based on the scan, a particular style or size of orthotic is recommended. Oyher custom orthotics are available by prescription. A doctor performs a medical assessment of person’s body, level of discomfort, and health history. This professional determines the most appropriate material to be used. Then, impressions of the feet are taken.

Most Common Conditions Helped with Custom Orthotics

There are many different conditions that improve with the use of custom orthotics.

  • Metatarsalalgia. This occurs when there is an inflammation between the metatarsal bones in the foot. This results from wearing ill-fitting shoes, improper walking, or increased activity. Orthotics help to decompress joints and to restore regular movement in feet.
  • Plantar Fasciitis. The planter fascia is tissue that offers support to a foot’s arch. Also, it acts like a shock absorber. When a person has a flat arch without support, this part of the foot can tear and cause pain. A custom orthotic restores an arch’s height, which prevents new damage.
  • Low Back Pain. Foot problems can cause negative effects in other parts of the body. For instance, if a person’s legs are different lengths, the pelvis tilts. This places pressure on the lower back muscles. By using orthotic lifts, alignment is restored so that pain is eliminated.

Orthopedic Shoes vs Custom Orthotics

When a person experiences trouble with his or her feet, it is wise to invest in insoles or custom orthotics. However, the person must decide what option is better for individual problems (Orthopedic Shoes vs Custom Orthotics). People who want comfort during times when they will be on their feet will enjoy the cushioning that is provided by insoles. However, custom orthotics are better for conditions like flat feet, heel spurs, back pain, and similar ailments.

Besides relieving pain, they prevent issues by offering support, especially to the ankles. Orthotics can be a key part of comprehensive treatment to individuals who deal with foot and ankle issues.

Everyone is advised to wear shoes that fit properly, especially during athletic activities. If pain persists, it is wise to visit a healthcare professional for an evaluation. Prescription orthotics work for individuals with extreme foot deformities or diabetes.

Although these items are expensive, certain Medicare programs cover a portion of the cost. If the price is still too high, a person should consider an insole that is made of a rigid material, which offers support and stability. This helps with plantar facetious, overpronation, and structural misalignment. When a person’s feet are kept healthy and comfortable, the rest of the body will follow.

Custom Orthotics vs Insoles - Which is Right for You? (2024)

FAQs

Custom Orthotics vs Insoles - Which is Right for You? ›

People who want comfort during times when they will be on their feet will enjoy the cushioning that is provided by insoles. However, custom orthotics are better for conditions like flat feet, heel spurs, back pain, and similar ailments.

Are custom orthotics better than insoles? ›

Not all prefabricated insoles are made alike, however, especially when it comes to the level of support they offer. While scientific research has proven that insoles help treat and prevent leg, foot and lower-extremity injuries, studies have not found a significant difference between prefabricated and custom orthotics.

How do I know if I need custom orthotics? ›

Reasons Why You Need Custom Orthotics
  1. You Have Structural Issues in Your Feet. Your feet could be lacking the support they need due to their anatomy – particularly if you have high arches or flatfoot. ...
  2. You Stand for Hours Every Day. ...
  3. Your Shoes Are Old or Worn Out. ...
  4. You Are Experiencing Pain in Your Foot.
Mar 27, 2020

Do insoles count as orthotics? ›

The main difference between an insole and an orthotic is that insoles do not address specific foot disorders. Instead, insoles are mass-produced, usually require the user to trim them with scissors to fit their shoes and provide general cushioning pain relief.

Do orthotics correct your feet? ›

A doctor-designed orthotic will control the alignment and function of your foot. These orthotics will treat or prevent abnormal motion, or rolling, of the foot. By redistributing the pressure on the bottom of your feet, you'll reduce discomfort, pain and calluses.

What are the negatives of orthotics? ›

One major issue is that custom orthotics can be quite expensive, and may not be covered by insurance. Additionally, some people find them uncomfortable or difficult to adjust to, especially if they are used to wearing regular shoes without any additional support.

Why do my custom orthotics hurt my arch? ›

They were not fitted properly

An improper fit is The most common reason these devices cause any discomfort. This problem is likely with off-the-shelf devices that incorrectly conform to your foot shape. Occasionally, custom orthotics may also fit incorrectly, leading to rubbing or aching.

How much should custom orthotics cost? ›

There are many types of custom orthotics, and they can cost anywhere from $300 to $800. Semi-custom orthotics cost between $60 and $300, and basic off-the-shelf inserts are available for as little as $10 to $20. Some health insurance plans won't pay for custom-made orthotics.

What is the alternative to custom orthotics? ›

Semi-custom Insoles. Semi-custom insoles offer the best of both worlds to people looking for relief from foot pain. Offering more individualized features than the generic, over-the-counter inserts you'll find at the drugstore or Walmart, semi-custom insoles are also significantly less expensive than custom orthotics.

What is the life expectancy of custom orthotics? ›

While a typical custom orthotic might last around 2-3 years on average, not every case is a typical one. Some people need theirs replaced every year, while others can get 5 years or more (occasionally much more) of use out of theirs.

Do I remove original insoles when using orthotics? ›

In most cases, we recommend that you remove the insole, or footbed, from your shoes and replace them with your custom foot orthotics. Most shoes that are compatible with orthotics have a removable footbed that allows your custom foot orthotics to fit inside comfortably.

Are orthotics a sham? ›

The combined studies showed “foot orthoses [were] not superior for improving pain and function compared with [a] sham,” the researchers wrote.

Should you wear orthotics all day? ›

The Right Time To Wear Orthotics

After 2 weeks, wearing time should be up to 8 hours a day. If you experience a time delay in this wearing program due to pain or dysfunction, please contact your physician or therapist and reduce your wearing time to the last level of best comfort.

Are orthotics better than insoles? ›

Orthotics are in the same category as inserts. However, they are custom fit. Insoles are manufactured to help the masses, but orthotics are specially crafted for one person's feet. Since they fit perfectly, effectiveness is increased.

What are the best orthopedic insoles? ›

  • Walk Hero Plantar Fasciitis Feet Insoles. $19.99. Amazon. $24.85. ...
  • Dr. Scholl's Sport Insoles. $15.77. Amazon. $20.49. ...
  • Aetrex Lynco Women's Complete Orthotics. $69.95. Aetrex.
  • Superfeet All-Purpose Women's High-Impact Support Insoles. $59.95. Amazon. ...
  • Sof Sole Insoles Men's Athlete Performance Full-Length Gel Shoe Insert. $17.97. Amazon.
May 6, 2024

Are custom orthotics worth it? ›

Orthotics are invaluable to overweight people because they can help reduce the impact on the ligaments of their lower bodies. It can help to reduce pain. Custom orthotics can help those with arthritis, diabetes, and chronic pain by improving gait and reducing muscle and ligament strain.

How long do custom orthotics last? ›

While a typical custom orthotic might last around 2-3 years on average, not every case is a typical one. Some people need theirs replaced every year, while others can get 5 years or more (occasionally much more) of use out of theirs. In other words, it really is a case-by-case thing.

What is the success rate of orthotics? ›

Studies indicate that orthotics are highly effective, with an 89% success rate in reducing pain associated with plantar fascia degeneration [9].

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Otha Schamberger

Last Updated:

Views: 5792

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (75 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Otha Schamberger

Birthday: 1999-08-15

Address: Suite 490 606 Hammes Ferry, Carterhaven, IL 62290

Phone: +8557035444877

Job: Forward IT Agent

Hobby: Fishing, Flying, Jewelry making, Digital arts, Sand art, Parkour, tabletop games

Introduction: My name is Otha Schamberger, I am a vast, good, healthy, cheerful, energetic, gorgeous, magnificent person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.