Rigid Versus Soft Orthotics (2024)

Rigid Versus Soft Orthotics (1)

Different types of orthotics offer varying levels of support and relief for foot discomfort. Understanding the distinctions between rigid and soft orthotics can help you determine which type is best suited for your needs. Orthotics' stiffness depends on the materials used, such as flexible foam or solid hard plastic. While rigid orthotics provide enhanced stability and support, they may require a break-in period and are commonly made of hard plastic. They are ideal for conditions like plantar fasciitis or flat feet that require arch support. On the other hand, soft orthotics, typically composed of EVA, a soft elastic type of plastic, excel at relieving pressure on sensitive areas of the feet. Recommended for individuals engaged in high-impact sports, soft orthotics adapt to problem areas, cushion the feet, and provide arch support. If you experience foot discomfort, it is suggested that you consult with a podiatrist for an assessment that can help determine if orthotics are right for you and which type may offer the most benefits.

If you are having discomfort in your feet and would like to try orthotics, contact Franklin Harry, DPM from Best Foot Forward. Our doctor can provide the care you need to keep you pain-free and on your feet.

What Are Orthotics?

Orthotics are inserts you can place into your shoes to help with a variety of foot problems such as flat feet or foot pain. Orthotics provide relief and comfort for minor foot and heel pain but can’t correct serious biomechanical problems in your feet.

Over-the-Counter Inserts

Orthotics come in a wide variety of over-the-counter inserts that are used to treat foot pain, heel pain, and minor problems. For example, arch supports can be inserted into your shoes to help correct overarched or flat feet, while gel insoles are often used because they provide comfort and relief from foot and heel pain by alleviating pressure.

Prescription Orthotics

If over-the-counter inserts don’t work for youor if you have a more severe foot concern, it is possible to have your podiatrist prescribe custom orthotics. These high-quality inserts are designed to treat problems such as abnormal motion, plantar fasciitis, and severe forms of heel pain. They can even be used to help patients suffering from diabetes by treating foot ulcers and painful callusesand are usually molded to your feet individually, which allows them to provide full support and comfort.

If you are experiencing minor to severe foot or heel pain, it’s recommended to speak with your podiatrist about the possibilities of using orthotics. A podiatrist can determine which type of orthotic is right for you and allow you to take the first steps towards being pain-free.

If you have any questions please contact our offices located in Festus and St. Louis, MO and Sauget, IL . We offer the newest diagnostic and treatment technologies for all your foot and ankle needs.

Rigid Versus Soft Orthotics (2024)

FAQs

Rigid Versus Soft Orthotics? ›

Rigid orthotics control motion in the two major foot joints that lie directly below the ankle joint and may improve or eliminate strains, aches, and pains in the legs, thighs, and lower back. Soft orthotics are generally used to absorb shock, increase balance, and take pressure off uncomfortable or sore spots.

Are soft or hard orthotics better? ›

Softer orthotics are more flexible because they bend with your feet. Each type is appropriate for different foot conditions. Rigid orthotics are good for those who have plantar fasciitis or Achilles tendonitis. This type of orthotic takes more time to adjust to but over time becomes more comfortable.

What is the difference between rigid and flexible orthotics? ›

Rigid orthotics are harder on the feet and your feet may require some time to adjust. Soft orthotics Soft insoles are made of materials like EVA foam and gel. They are the best when the goal is to provide cushion or support, improve shock absorption, increase balance, and pressure relief.

Are hard or soft insoles better for flat feet? ›

The short answer? Firm arch supports for feet that are flat are better. Flat, floppy gel or foam insoles are missing the support your feet need to keep your joints problem-free.

What are rigid orthotics for? ›

Rigid orthotics control motion in the two major foot joints that lie directly below the ankle joint and may improve or eliminate strains, aches, and pains in the legs, thighs, and lower back. Soft orthotics are generally used to absorb shock, increase balance, and take pressure off uncomfortable or sore spots.

Why do my feet hurt so bad with orthotics? ›

An improper fit is The most common reason these devices cause any discomfort. This problem is likely with off-the-shelf devices that incorrectly conform to your foot shape. Occasionally, custom orthotics may also fit incorrectly, leading to rubbing or aching.

How long do rigid orthotics last? ›

You may need a new pair of hard plastic custom orthotics every three to five years. But if they're built of soft plastic or foam, you may have to replace them annually. How often you wear them also affects how long they will last. In general, most of our patients with orthotics are instructed to wear them at all times.

How do I know if my flat feet are rigid or flexible? ›

There are two types of pes planus, or flatfoot: flexible flatfoot and rigid flatfoot. For an individual with flexible flatfoot, their arches are normal when they are sitting or on their tiptoes, but collapse when they stand. With rigid flatfoot, the arch of the foot remains flattened despite the foot's position.

Are rigid shoes better for plantar fasciitis? ›

Supporting the arch

On a practical note what I've seen clinically is that rigid arch supports sometimes aggravate symptoms due to pressure over the tender plantar fascia so a cushioned arch support may be a good choice.

What are the disadvantages of orthotics? ›

Disadvantages:
  • Not designed for your foot type or foot pathology.
  • Thick and bulky.
  • Difficult to fit into footwear.
  • Low durability – 6 months.
Apr 20, 2020

Are rigid orthotics good for plantar fasciitis? ›

While rigid orthotics provide enhanced stability and support, they may require a break-in period and are commonly made of hard plastic. They are ideal for conditions like plantar fasciitis or flat feet that require arch support.

Why do arch supports hurt my flat feet? ›

Your insoles may be hurting your feet because they're not the right arch height, are too rigid or too flexible, are not the right style for your footwear, or the arch placement isn't working for your feet. For insoles that don't hurt your feet, looking for ones that offer a choice of arch heights.

Are hard orthotics better than soft? ›

Polypropelene (Hard Device) Pros:

Will last a lot longer than a soft EVA orthotic, as the foot orthoses will not flatten or compress over time. Can influence the foot better as it is able to apply more force to certain areas. Very low profile to fit into fashion footwear or casual shoes.

Which insoles do podiatrists recommend? ›

PowerStep Pinnacle® Orthotic Insoles

Podiatrists often recommend our PowerStep Pinnacle insoles specifically for plantar fasciitis pain. These orthotic insoles for heel pain can be worn daily for cushioned relief plus support.

How do I know which orthotics I need? ›

  1. Wear your favorite shoes to get orthotics fitted. ...
  2. Understand your foot type and condition. ...
  3. Consider the types of activities you need orthotics for. ...
  4. Seek professional advice or a prescription. ...
  5. Get custom orthotics, built for your individual foot.

How long do soft orthotics last? ›

While a typical custom orthotic might last around 2-3 years on average, not every case is a typical one. Some people need theirs replaced every year, while others can get 5 years or more (occasionally much more) of use out of theirs.

What is the best material for foot orthotics? ›

Functional foot orthotics are usually made from thinner, firmer materials. Subortholen, polypropylene, copolymer, and the carbon graphite composites are all good choices for functional devices. Usually they will incorporate a deep heel cup and a good medial longitudinal arch.

Are hard or soft soles better for plantar fasciitis? ›

In general a softer, more cushioned shoe is better than a hard shoe in slowing down the speed of the plantar fascia elongation.

Is it good to wear orthotics all the time? ›

How often you wear your inserts depends on why you're wearing them, but in general, your custom orthotics are much more effective when you wear them consistently. Custom orthotics are designed to help support your feet and correct abnormal motion while you are using them.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Rev. Leonie Wyman

Last Updated:

Views: 6143

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (79 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Rev. Leonie Wyman

Birthday: 1993-07-01

Address: Suite 763 6272 Lang Bypass, New Xochitlport, VT 72704-3308

Phone: +22014484519944

Job: Banking Officer

Hobby: Sailing, Gaming, Basketball, Calligraphy, Mycology, Astronomy, Juggling

Introduction: My name is Rev. Leonie Wyman, I am a colorful, tasty, splendid, fair, witty, gorgeous, splendid person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.