What type of cookie-lover are you? Do you like crispy or soft cookies? Sweet or tangy? Chocolate chunks or dainty chips? Dipped in milk or served with tea? Whatever type of cookie fills your cravings, we can all agree that homemade cookies are the best, especially if they are still warm out of the oven.
But what if you don’t have time to bake? No worries, packaged cookies are a perfectly acceptable substitute. The cookie section in your local grocery store is full of popular cookie brands to satisfy your cookie needs. The best store-bought cookies are so delicious that even your Mom won’t be able to tell them apart from homemade.
Are you craving something new? Is it time to refill the cookie jar with your favorite cookie? Discover some of the yummiest cookies to tantalize your taste buds. We’ve got the cookies you crave. Pour yourself a glass of milk and dig in.
1. OREO Double Stuf Chocolate Sandwich Cookies
Some cookie brands never go out of style. Take the classic OREO Double Stuf. A thick layer of delectable cream sandwiched between two classic chocolate sandwich cookies. You can’t have just one! Eat whole, dunk in milk, or break ‘em apart and lick the cream. Anything goes.
2. Milk Bar Confetti Cookies
When rainbows meet cookies, you know you’re in for a treat. Milk Bar has added confetti sprinkles to its classic sugar cookie recipe. The result is a buttery, vanilla-infused confection with a burst of colorful sprinkles perfect for celebrations of all kinds.
3. Sweet Street Salted Caramel Manifesto Cookie
Sweet Street’s intentions are clear. They bake the best salted-caramel treat anywhere. Every batch of cookies starts with all-butter, pure cane sugar, and cage-free eggs. The Salted Caramel Manifesto Cookie is the perfect capper to a great lunch hour.
4. Belgian Boys Raspberry Cookie Tarts
There’s no argument; nothing beats a French dessert. Belgian Boys prove it by covering a crunchy buttery base with sweet delicious raspberry jam to craft a rich and luscious confection. These treats are made in France with real butter, sugar, and the ethos of indulgence baked right in.
5. Milano Double Dark Chocolate Cookies
Who says you can’t do better than perfect? Pepperidge Farms have gone one better with their Milano Double Dark Chocolate cookies. They’ve added dark chocolate’s rich, delicious flavor to their crisp, buttery cookies for a truly indulgent treat.
6. Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies
Whoever said don’t play with your food never ate a Nutter Butter cookie. These peanut butter cookies are so cute that you can’t help yourself. Nabisco makes them with real peanut butter; these are the perfect treat for the peanut lover. They’re ideal for adding a little savory sweetness to your snack drawer.
7. Keebler Fudge Stripe King Size Cookies
Those Keebler Elves are at it again! They’ve added a delicious chocolate layer to the bottom of their delightful sweet and crispy shortbread cookies. But they couldn’t stop. They put even more fudgy stripes on the top, making Fudge Stripe Cookies the pride of the Hollow Tree.
8. Walkers Pure Butter Shortbread Fingers
Taste the tradition. Walkers Shortbread Fingers are melt in your mouth delicious thanks to a combination of premium natural ingredients and a family recipe that has been perfected over the last century. Their shortbread has a unique crunchy yet crumbly texture to delight even the pickiest cookie eater.
9. Partake Gluten-Free Vegan Crunchy Birthday Cake Cookies
Surprise! You can have your cake and eat it too! Partake has created a birthday cake cookie you can feel good about, whether or not it’s your special day. Partake cookies are vegan, allergy-friendly, and non-GMO, making them the gift that keeps on giving.
10. Lofthouse 2-Pack Lofthouse Cookies
You can’t go wrong with a good sugar cookie. Lofthouse combines a soft sugar cookie with the perfect amount of buttercream frosting. Add some delightful sprinkles, and you have a cookie confection perfect for sharing. Or not. We won’t tell.
11. Chips Ahoy! Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies
The one! The only! The iconic Chips Ahoy! You can’t get much better than the tasty, chewy cookie wrapped around the perfect amount of sweet chips. These are some of the best chocolate chip cookies you can get in-store. It’s the classic chocolate chip cookie recipe baked to tender perfection. Just add milk.
FAQ
What is the most popular packaged cookie?
People love cookies. If there was any doubt, go to the grocery store. The cookie aisle is overflowing with variety. There are hundreds of options to choose from that’ll suit every taste possible. What’s most popular depends on what you’re in the mood for.
Plain and Simple. Nilla Wafers are perfect when you want an uncomplicated treat.
Tried and True. Nothing beats a traditional, buttery shortbread cookie from the Highlands of Scotland.
Sugar and Spice. Gingersnap cookies are everything nice about a cookie. Sweet, crispy, and delicious.
Cookies and Cream. Who can resist opening up an OREO Cookie or a Nutter Butter cookie and licking the frosting? No one, that's who.
Whatever you’re craving, you can find the perfect cookie confection at your favorite store.
What is the number one selling cookie?
It’s hard to beat deliciously sweet vanilla cream sandwiched between two crispy chocolate wafers. So it’s no surprise that the iconic OREO cookie is the number one selling cookie. They’ve been a popular choice among cookie lovers since 1912.
Since its launch, OREOs has reinvented itself multiple times. It started with OREO Double Stuf (1974) — the same Oreo cookies you love, only with twice the cream filling. Then they experimented with tastes, creating the OREO Golden variety (2004) and OREO Mint cookies (2019) as a limited edition, a trend that continues today. They even collaborated in 2021 with Lady Gaga to celebrate the release of the Chromatica album. You can even buy OREO Minis when you’re craving a little cookie for a bite-sized snack.
With their flair for invention, there’s no doubt that Oreos will continue to dominate the cookie aisle for years to come.
What cookie is America’s favorite?
The most famous American cookie is also its favorite: the Chocolate Chip Cookie. What’s not to love? It’s the perfect combination of butter, brown sugar, vanilla, nuts, and chocolate. It’s an incredibly versatile cookie. You can change the flavor by adding or removing nuts, using milk chocolate chips instead of dark, and cooking them until crisp like a wafer or chewy like a brownie.
This classic chocolate chip cookie dough bakes into a perfect chocolatey delight. Enjoy this chocolate flavor with a scoop of ice cream and semisweet chocolate sauce for a decadent dessert. Or do some experimenting and taste test with other ingredients! We won’t judge.
We’re convinced. There’s nothing better than a chocolate chip cookie.
